Plymouth, Indiana · North Township · A public comment

900 acres. Over 100 residents spoke. The vote was 9–0.

900
acres annexed and rezoned for industrial use
1,000+
people nearby affected, by the author’s estimate
100+
residents at the plan commission meeting
9–0
plan commission vote; the city council was unanimous too

Good morning.

I would like to provide some thoughts on the recent vote by the Plymouth Plan Commission on annexation and rezoning of 900 acres for industrial use. While the county is vastly limited on decisions such as this, you do have a responsibility to provide representation on the city plan commission and board of zoning appeals through appointments from the two-mile zone.

Based on the recent vote, I do not feel as though our current two-mile representatives are responsive to the concerns of the residents who live north of current city boundaries, which will soon extend a mile into North Township. Between residential developments on the east side of Lilac Road, east of the airport, and those on the west side of Michigan Road, I estimate over 1,000 people are impacted by this recent decision. Over 100 people attended the plan commission meeting and expressed concerns. The vote passed 9-0.

At church, one attendee at that meeting told me she felt that it was pointless that she went because they weren’t listened to. When the proposal went to the city council, more spoke about their concerns with questions that couldn’t be answered. It passed unanimously.

I don’t oppose the annexation, in fact, I had written a letter of support for that aspect of it specifically. And I don’t necessarily oppose industrial use, however, once zoned for that use, it would have to be rezoned to achieve any residential or commercial uses as has been suggested by the owners.

My issue is that concerns raised by residents were ignored, by their own representatives.

These concerns could have been addressed through more thoughtful planning with concessions, conditions, or restrictions. None were proposed by the city or given critical consideration by the plan commission. A full 900-acre industrial development in a community our size, with no defining elements, is planning malpractice at a colossal scale. That seems to be incompetence at best or intentional at worse.

I’ve known the property owners for 45 years, consider them friends, and know them to be honest and good people. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I’m led to believe they’ve been poorly advised by the city.

I have no faith in our representation on the planning boards. This has been the second big, controversial decision that has been made despite opposition by North Township residents in the last few years. The CAFO also received a unanimous vote by the city BZA. I would encourage the board of commissioners to ensure a more democratic level of representation on those boards, which currently seem skewed to Plymouth’s east and southside suburbs with little thought to how it affects people north of the city.

Thank you.

Kurt West Garner